1989 – MICHAEL D. DINGMAN
Corporate Leadership
1991 – GUY A. POLHEMUS
Humanitarian Endeavor
1992 – ROBERT ROY SCHENCK, M.D.
Excellence in Surgery
1993 – ANDREW A. HENDRICKS
Historical Endeavors
1994 – TWEED ROOSEVELT
Exploration and Science
1995 – DAVID WILLIAM VOORHEES
Historic Research and Publication
1996 – JOHN H. UPDIKE
American Literature
1997 – JAMES M. VAN BUREN, II
Service to the Society
1998 – Dr. JOHN R. VOORHIS, III
Service to the Society
1999 – THE HON. GREGORY W. CARMAN
Jurisprudence
2000 – ROBERT M. QUACKENBUSH
Art and Literature
2001 – FERDINAND L. WYCKOFF, JR.
Service to the Society
2002 – KENNETH HEWES BARRICKLO
Historic Preservation
2003 – DAVID M. RIKER
Genealogy
2004 – PETER VAN DYKE
Service to the Society
2005 – PETER H. B. FRELINGHUYSEN
Public Service
2006 – JOHN O. DELAMATER
Service to the Society
2007 – ADRIAN T. BOGART, JR.
Service to the Society
2008 – WILLIAM VAN WINKLE
Service to the Society
2009 – CHARLES ZABRISKIE, JR.
Service to the Society
2010 – JAMES R. VAN WAGNER, JR.
Service to the Society
2011 – KENNETH GRANT WINANS
Excellence in Finance and History
2012 – EDWIN OUTWATER
Excellence in Music
2013 – RALPH L. DEGROFF, Jr.
Service to the Society
2014 – DONALD WESTERVELT
Service to the Society
2015 – COL. ADRIAN T. BOGART III
Service to Country and the Society